Monday, June 12, 2017

Trust, Popularity, and Earning Respect


 

President Trump
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave.
Washington D.C.
12 June 2017 

Dear President Trump, 

It is perhaps presumptuous for me, a regular citizen, to give advice to the president.  It is a hard job you have and I readily acknowledge that.  On the other hand, our country was founded on the principle that the chief executive is a citizen, no more, no less.  So please allow me to offer you some suggestions.

Sir, according to today’s Gallup poll, nearly two thirds of the American people disapprove of your actions as president.  While there are certainly plenty of policy reasons for this, I believe that much of it comes down to a matter of not being able to trust you.  And I think much of the reason that they do not trust you is that you are not being honest, particularly with yourself.

This morning you held an open cabinet meeting in which you asked every cabinet member to tell the reporters present how great you are.  However, because they are your cabinet, appointed by you and beholden to you for their jobs, this is not a particularly convincing tactic.  Last week, James Comey testified about his meetings with you.  While I am not sure that he is completely trustworthy either, when you immediately tell the American people that his testimony was false without conceding that some of it may have had some truth in it, it makes you seem on the defensive and less trustworthy.

Sir, everyone makes mistakes, and almost everyone who has held office has admitted to making mistakes – starting with George Washington (read his final address and you will see he leads off with that theme).  You seem incapable of conceding that you too are fallible.  Your repeated claims that you are the best at everything, that your efforts have been record-breaking, and that everything is going wonderfully – all that rings hollow when considered in light of what you have actually accomplished and failed to accomplish.

You have failed to appoint people to fill a great many positions in your administration.  You have failed in your attempted travel ban, which was found unconstitutional on the grounds of discriminating against a particular religion.  You have failed to propose any significant new legislation – including a replacement to the health care system you wish to get rid of.  You have had a series of foreign policy mishaps, most recently alienating our NATO allies by demanding they unilaterally increase their payments,  In fact, most of what you have done has been cutting protections, regulations, and laws designed to protect the American people. 

Now actually, since you are only near the beginning of your presidency, it is not like anyone would have expected you to have accomplished that much --  but by refusing to acknowledge that you might not be perfect, you are setting yourself up for failure.  Hubris brings about its own demise.  Humility would serve you much better.

One of the best ways to turn that situation around might be to start listening to what the American people have to say – not only those who are devotees of Fox News, and not just those who you know will flatter you -- but everyone.  Listen to the concerns that Americans have for clean water and air, for the risk of climate change, for health care issues, for the rising tide of racist incidents, and for other issues.  Then take those concerns seriously, admit that the problems are complex, and try to do something about them that will benefit all Americans. 

If you did that, you might discover the difference between popularity and respect.  Please consider these words.

Regards,

Bill Boerman-Cornell

 

No comments:

Post a Comment